TWICE Performs 'Moonlight Sunrise' On The Kelly Clarkson Show

@kevindxniel “that’s coming from someone who likes twice” and proceeds to discredit them

All kpop idols doing a lip sync also BP lol..

It’s obviously pre recorded vocals. Anyone who watches a lot of pop performances would know in an instant. No rocket science. But i love this song!

It’s pre recorded . we don’t need to hear those unstable vocals and that’s coming from someone who likes twice.

Absolutely

So right ❤❤❤

@A AYB the backing track is very low though, and it was only useful for the extended high notes that they couldn’t manage because they were dancing.

@A AYB If this was pre-recorded, how did they let sana sound like she's sick? 💀

@tsukasa are you mentioning the right person? Check your comment and mine please. There is nothing you said that has anything to do with what I said. I was responding to another person saying shit about prerecorded and lip-syncing. Those are not the opposite of each other. What you meant I guess was a playback. A playback and a prerecorded version are the exact same thing. Look it up. When you sing over a playback, you are partially lip syncing. So no, that’s not 100% live. While backing track is a another different thing, which usually is a recorded track of instruments or accompaniment vocals. So no, what they said was prerecorded and that’s not at all a backing track! What do you want to argue? I am happy to be educated.

​​@A AYB nourr u just jealous u cant sing like em, they are clearly struggling in some parts but its not that obvious

@ruu M oh my bad. I didn’t realize about the pre-recorded track yet I don’t think their lip-syncing?? Idk what I think completely know anyway they still did great I’ll just have to watch it again haha

@ALL ROUNDER it's ok l don't care still their voices also they are so tired so they don't have to sing live always

it's pre recording, look at jihyo's lips 2:20 🤣🤣🤣

@A AYB fans just decided to be blind/deaf and go comment something like "their live vocals sound so stable" like be fr for once

​@Pereira Matau finally someone who can hear properly!! I like Twice and this song is really enjoyable but ppl gotta stop praising "live" vocals when everything is either pre-recorded or lip-sync...it's so sad because they can sing - jihyo, jeongyeon and nayeon are even good singers - but K-pop now is so focused on reaching perfection; physical appearance, stage presence and hard choreos are now more important than actual live singers...

​@Steve C you can clearly hear it LIVE

@Simon Shaheen sorry to say this but, it's fans like this who make me lose interest on some idols.

@Elizabeth Lily the same goes for u guys out there why don't you all let the fans have our moment if we love some artists you should respect our feelings too we didn't start this idiocy we the fans were sharing our feelings and excitement we didn't bother anyone

@Simon Shaheen wow sisterrrr, calm down. I just don't agree with what you wrote on comment section. If you're not prepared to hear others opinion then best to keep it to yourselr

@yuyu yunho I don't have any problem s with asian fans. I just saying that the world is not represented by some countries only.

​@Isidora Corona GorriñoShe sounded great wtf

​@A AYBIt's absolutely live

@Ricki Kookie i don't think that answering to literally 3 comments on here is being on "every comment", but okay... but also, I do care about this issue. As I listen to Twice from time to time and as a kpop fan since the 2nd generation, it's just alarming to me that people now can't hear the difference between live vocals, pre-recorded vocals, and lip-sync.

​@A AYB bro you are on every comment, too much work for someone who isn't a hater 😅

did you hear sana?? if this wasn’t live, do you think they would let her sound this bad?

@nisrine^⁴blink dude us blinks should not act like this, grow up 😑 I’m sorry once, dealing with blinks like this😒 I will always support TWICE even if I’m a blink💖

@I am Devil of my World.. hahaha you're a little hurt, are you going to take your life for that? Well, if even people criticized not only his repetitive music, even his rap, and he was looked at a lot because of the controversy that he had cultural appropriation, and whose voice are you talking about? The voice that you don't usually have live? No matter what they tell you about your idol, she will continue to be perfect for you, so I don't see any reason for you to keep trying to make the rest see how "great" she is, and unless you come to something that is not about she's going to make you hurt XD, look, I'll put it like this, if Lisa sings badly and is wrong, you would say "she's so cute, she does sing live" but if another idol does it, you criticize her, you're so blind because of fanaticism , understand that not only your brand new Lisa exists, even if it hurts, just as there are about a thousand other artists, Blackpink did not pave the way for anyone, the only one who can actually say something like that is BTS, those are true sources because they even came out at UNICEF, haha ​​it's ironic, I don't see any army arguing because another group is relevant, only blink seems to be afraid that there is someone else xD, what could I expect from an envious fandon who accuses Bts of being misogenic in their songs just because they are successful? the end, that's what happens, someone is successful and blink dies of worry, the worst thing is that you will surely kill yourself with anger and all the idols that you criticize with your favorites must be there, or is that it? envy? not fulfill your frustrated dream of being able to have them close at least? xD you are dying for something that at most you can go to a concert.

@Benjiro Moon Kang And You are saying Me to rest This Also allows for LaLisa... Say me LaLisa Just Reminding Of This What about Her Rap verse, Bridges part Her Vocals,Her Representing own Hometown... Just remembering That' Part ..LaLisa Is also a best Song Just People like U just barking her on Say me LaLisa Love me When this is only Her Chorus Part.. Just bullshit Things

@nisrine^⁴blink I bet if TWICE hopped off the fame of American artists like Selena Gomez then I’m sure they would place top charts 😂🤭

@s' I agree they are the biggest, but they aren’t going to last long with Jennie dragging down the group with her bored expressions. At this point, she’s more of an Instagram model than a idol.

@Miss play Kpop fans call their favorite girl groups "queens" every day, for the record I use the term less often than most but you're going to call me out on it? Okay then, I'll explain it another way. You said you're talking about the music. NewJeans has released a few hit songs that are very popular. A FEW songs. That's it. Twice has released dozens of great songs and had many hit title tracks. That's why I said you should wait a few years before claiming they're the best.

​@Miss play Their songs are fire, but still twice has more popularity and sells than new jeans (clearly not a competition because new jeans is from 4th generation and omg they're eating and left no crumbs).

​@s' are you nuts? BP may be the biggest girl group, but that doesn't mean it's the best.

But they are the biggest k pop group. Wth with you?

I think is live, sometimes I hear them be out of breath for lines like Sana on the last line

Some of y'all just can't admit the fact they are singing live like hello stop hating there is no room here for your opinion even when ur literally wrong ....🥴🤦‍♂️

​@•Cold Indigo• fr lmao

​@Furstnayme LassnaimNot at all

LOL, twice not live, this is pre recording. Look at jihyo's lips 2:20 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@Jay mer You can hear Sana and Mina struggling with breathing clearly, tf is wrong with haters, y'all are just deaf asf 😭

Si cantan demasiado bien increíble chicas y demaciado humildes y simpáticas

Solo verdades🛐🛐

YESSSSS !!!!!!!

The right answer 👀

yes!

Yesss ❤✨

@Steve C use headphone or, better, use your brain

@Steve Cit actually is. Stop trying to discredit them

Too bad it wasn't actually live.

Cry on me was virtually live but this one is in person

@Shawn Thorington I know someone mentioned some songs with her deep voice, but love foolish is a great example!

@Supreme^90s you can literally hear them gasping for air, also they r moving a lot in general so they obviously can't sing without it sounding messy ☠️ also, a few words were mispronounced and you can hear it.

@Supreme^90s I didn't say they are singing live are you blind?

they are lipsyncing..

@Nada Abdelkhalek i think the same, honestly sana’s chours sounds bad, if this was pre-recorded they would’t let her sounds this way

@Ricardo ! Sorry but no one cares.

💯 pre-recorded

Sorry, but this is pre-recorded

@divadream this is not prerecorded vocals, this is live

And Kelly is the mother of them, the mutual feelling and respect is so stroong

YEEEEES

​@Joseph Emanuel Sorry, but I did see her chest moving. The camera was also on movement and you can't really appreciate it, but yes she does take a big breath and you can see it. I've made the same breath as her and your chest doesn't move in an exaggerated way.

​@Joseph Emanuel maybe because that wasn't her line but Sana's line? 😂

​@Danielle they never discredit them ☠️☠️ I'm once and I can clearly say this is pre-recorded. They use this technique where they even record heavy breathing to make it look more real. No one is saying they sing bad or anything. Admitting they lip sync doesn't make you less fan

@Panic Xie can you tag the time

1:11 momo saying arr and not all fuz she's not fluet in english 1:38mina taking a breath ??wth

This was not live vocals, lol.

Everything about this performance was just right

Me too i was in tears as well

​@Litzyy I can't believe people actually can't hear that this isn't live. It's pre-recorded, and it sounds like full lip-sync for some members. I've heard Twice sing live in other performances, but this isn't one of them!

As someone who has been watching and listening to twice live stages, I can tell when they are singing live and this is definitely not live unfortunately. Jihyo, nayeon, jeongyeon usually sound more powerful when they sing live and mina and chaeyoung a little quieter. Don't get me wrong I love them and we onces know what twice is capable of 😍

​@ᄏᄏᄏJIMINeutron But Sana sounds like she's struggling a bit as well as Tzuyu and if the vocals were to be pre-recorded I guess they would sound a bit more stable! But that's my guess though

@CCK Myuxun basing from their encores, this is too good to be true. they have trouble hitting notes while standing up, all the more while dancing. they sound too perfect to be singing live while dancing...

@Steve C bruh you don't have money don't ya?

Yeah, it wasn't live vocals, though.