The Shocking Alternative by C.S. Lewis Doodle (BBC Talk 8, Mere Christianity, Bk 2, Chapter 3)

Vistas 58 617
98% 1 302 18

Notes: This is an illustration of C.S Lewis’ third talk of the third radio series called ‘What Christians Believe’. This became Chapter 3 of Book 2, in the book called ‘Mere Christianity’. Notes below...
You can find the book here: www.amazon.com/Mere-Christianity-C-S-Lewis/dp/0060652926
(0:05) This radio talk was given in February 1942 during some of Britain's darkest days in WWII, with major cities having experienced a series of bombing blitzes and about to experience more. The Axis powers were at the zenith of their power. Step up to the microphone, C.S. Lewis... (This radio talk was the first to be heard by the American G.I.’s who arrived in Britain the week before.)
(3:06) If you would like to think more about thought itself, see other doodles on the subject such as 'The Foundation of 20th Century thought' (esvid.net/video/v%C3%ADdeo-DH53uFBOGbw.html), and 'The Poison of Subjectivism' (esvid.net/video/v%C3%ADdeo-Lgcd6jvsCFs.html).
(6:27) At this time there was fuel rationing in wartime Britain. Many people tried to run their cars on alternatives to petrol - using different alcohols - and this inevitably failed as the engines overheated.
(8:03) In English folklore, John Barleycorn is a character who represents the crop of barley harvested each autumn. The character grew healthy and hale during the summer, was chopped down and slaughtered in his prime, and then processed into beer and whiskey so he lived once more. This ‘dying god myth’, copied into folklore from the patterns of nature, actually led C.S. Lewis to Christ - natures creator, as he explains here: esvid.net/video/v%C3%ADdeo-Uv4kx2QP4UM.htmlm59s
(12:13) This shortened version of the argument “Liar, Lunatic or Lord” included another two non-Christian hypotheses, “Exaggeration or Legend”, in Lewis' other writings. This armchair-psychologist's argument (that gospel writers were lunatics) and this literary non-scholar's argument (that the gospels were just novelettes) are usually based on unthinking atheistic assumptions that the existence of God or the miraculous is impossible based on "one of the sciences". Based on these assumptions, Jesus’ shocking acts or statements can not be true, and therefore some way, however implausible, is sought to remove or discredit the offending sayings and acts. However, these are not strong arguments in themselves without the false assumption fueling them. Lewis counters these basic philosophic errors (illustrated in doodle form) in ‘Religion and Science’ (esvid.net/video/v%C3%ADdeo-AJu0oYvi-cY.html) and ‘Miracles’ (esvid.net/video/v%C3%ADdeo-BboJqrW8a8U.html).
Once the bias is dealt with, these two less likely possibilities can be addressed. Lewis' voluminous arguments against them can be found in the essays ‘What are We to Make of Jesus Christ’ (drive.google.com/file/d/0B9MmcPqIiEnKckRMZW8tVmxpeFk/view?usp=sharing), ‘Fern-Seed and Elephants’, ‘Myth became Fact’, ‘The Grand Miracle’, ‘Christian Apologetics’ and other works.

Publicado el


21 ago 2017

C.S. LewisThe Shocking AlternativeMere ChristianityBBC






Mi lista de reproducción
Ver despues
Comentarios 27
Jason Anthony
Jason Anthony Hace 3 meses
Excellent work here, it must have taken you many hours to complete each of these... a real labour of love. Many thanks for your incredible commitment- your work is appreciated by thousands.
simbarashe shonhiwa
simbarashe shonhiwa Hace 6 meses
i was the 1000th person to like this ;)
Charlie Williams
Charlie Williams Hace 7 meses
Awesome doodle/video! You took a complex biblical principle and explained it in a way that anyone (believer or non-believer) could understand. Thank you!
Leonore Baulch
Leonore Baulch Hace 7 meses
Whenever I read this and now Seeing it in art form....wow...gives me chills.....of joy
Esaú Ponce
Esaú Ponce Hace un año
Wonderful video!
Chris Campbell
Chris Campbell Hace un año
Noah Productions [NP]
This is beautifully done. C. S. Lewis has so much wisdom, and your visuals and recorded narration couldn't add to it any better. Thank you, keep up the excellent work!
Red Shadow
Red Shadow Hace un año
Awesome keep it up. The best channel on ESvid.
maxgotsmart Hace un año
Doing great work, keep it up!
Michael Sculley
Michael Sculley Hace un año
When you (CSLewis Doodle) have the time, could you make a doodle about C.S.Lewis's response to David Hume's "Refutation of Miracles"? It's found in Lewis's book "Miracles". I don't remember which chapter, possibly the chapter was called something like "Response to Objections". (I do know that in the chapter in which Lewis addresses this argument of Humes', Lewis quotes David Hume at the beginning of the chapter). The reason I want to ask if you could do a Doodle about this, is because David Hume was an 18th century atheist Scottish philosopher, who is still widely known today for his argument against belief that miracles can happen.
CSLewisDoodle Hace un año
I’ve doodle a part of Lewis’ argument with Hume a few minutes into ‘The Grand Miracle’ but haven’t yet attempted the full chapter of ‘Miracles’ that brilliantly addresses him (Chapter 13). One of my favourite chapters.
Michael Adams
Michael Adams Hace un año
Very compelling argument
sam opoku
sam opoku Hace un año
Very good! Thank you so much for depicting Lewis' words in such an engaging way.
Grace Has Come
Grace Has Come Hace un año
Delawanna Hace un año
Love these!!!
salli4588 Hace un año
Absolutely excellent , as always. Thank you, brother. Love to you.
Jacob Roebuck
Jacob Roebuck Hace un año
Well done!
Joshua Taylor
Joshua Taylor Hace un año
This is my favorite ESvid channel! Keep up the good work.
Allan Lindsay
Allan Lindsay Hace un año
I do so love these presentations and must thank you once again for such splendid work. We are indebted to you so much not only for your skill, but also your research resulting in the in depth explanations which accompany such wonderful artwork .
RennyLFC Hace un año
Mind blown!!!
Jerkycam Hace un año
RennyLFC I had the same reaction. 😮
michael quinn
michael quinn Hace un año
Thank you so much for making This videos.
FanofAslan Hace un año
Wonderful words, very well produced here. Thank you!
InTheNameOfJustice Hace un año
IxEliteHD Hace un año
I hope you never lose motivation to do these they are so wonderful
CSLewisDoodle Hace un año
To those interested, a fuller essay version of this short radio talk is found below: drive.google.com/file/d/0B9MmcPqIiEnKSzZ5UWRwNGxFUnc/view?usp=sharing . See this doodle also: 'Religion and Science' by C.S. Lewis esvid.net/video/v%C3%ADdeo-AJu0oYvi-cY.html
Crabby Lobster
Crabby Lobster Hace un año
thanks for taking the time to do this, it is certainly refreshing to hear his understanding as well as see it in this format. God Bless!
A continuación
Swapping Boyfriends on Vacation
Can You Swim in Shade Balls?
Vistas 1 185 476